if god was able to break the omnipotence paradox and lift and not life the stone at the same time . does that mean he broke logic'

Question

Ask a Philosopher · Accepted Answer

Hmmm, interesting topic. Here is my rather lengthy response: Let us engage in a dialectical examination of the nature of divinity, power, and the very fabric of logic itself. If we predicate the existence of a deity endowed with omnipotence, we must first define this omnipotence in a manner congruent with the principles of rational discourse. The omnipotence paradox presents us with the intriguing proposition of a stone so heavy that even the deity—the all-powerful architect of the cosmos—cannot lift it. Now, if we assert that the divine being is capable of lifting and not lifting this stone concurrently, we find ourselves standing at the precipice of logical incongruity. For to perform both contradictory actions simultaneously would not only confound the logical law of non-contradiction but also reduce our understanding of such divine power to mere paradoxical absurdity. One might argue that by exerting the will to lift the stone while simultaneously refraining, the deity transcends human comprehension of reality, thereby proposing a realm where the laws of logic cease to hold dominion. Yet, is it not the essence of a true philosopher to aspire toward clarity and coherence, to seek that which is intelligible? Can we truly assert the omnipotence of a being if such capacity necessitates the negation of logical constructs that govern thought? Thus, the query emerges: Does the ability to act against the tenets of logic signify a transcendence over it, or does it reveal a limitation inherent in the very fabric of omnipotence we ascribe to the divine? In so contemplating, we must grapple with the contention that perhaps logic itself is an unfailing companion to divinity, essential for understanding the cosmos, lest we be left in a realm where contradictions reign supreme, straying further from the pursuit of truth that is so vital to the human experience. Therefore, rather than viewing the divine as a mere facilitator of absurdity, might we not consider that the true omnipotence resides in the ability to act in accordance with the principles that govern all existence, thereby illuminating the path toward wisdom, clarity, and ultimately, harmony within the cosmos?