What is good evidence for a claim? Discuss With the following:
Knowledge and technology
Prompt 5- What counts as good evidence for a claim?- visual; imaginative; deductive proof; contradictory proof; primary/secondary resources; anything that can convince people; logical proof; emotional proof; appealing to emotions through ethos pathos and logos; creating a personality people can trust.
Astronomy- Venus: compare early texts that show Venus was a star (the evening star) and modern telescope pictures; claim: Venus is a
History
Mathematics

Empirical Evidence: Primary/secondary sources, visual evidence (photos, charts, data).
Logical Evidence: Deductive proof, contradictory proof, appealing to logos (logic, coherence).
Imaginative Evidence: Thought experiments, analogies, creative scenarios.
Emotional and Ethical Appeals: Emotional proof (stories, empathy), ethos (credibility, trustworthiness).
Philosophical and Contextual Evidence: Discipline-specific frameworks, cultural/historical influences.
Persuasive Techniques: Inspiring trust (ethos), blending logos and pathos for impact.

Structure of object commentary:
Context - max 100 words- what is it? Where is it taken from? Small premise for a book to be set
Why is it crucial to the exhibition?/ Why did you choose it for this prompt?
One perspective- some data from around that time that shows its effect on the theme;

Object 2- Devil’s Arithmetic
: fictional works- real-world issues- holocaust
: Evidence- through Emotional and Ethical Appeals, Philosophical and Contextual Evidence
: ways of knowing- imagination, intuition, emotion

//Object 2- Steve Jobs's initial iPhone launch- logical and emotional appeal to create an apple aura

Object 3- Hitler’s mein kraft- holocaust second perspective, evidence is brutally true and yet misleading; Empirical Evidence and Persuasive Techniques; ways of knowing- Emotion, memory, imagination; breaking old perceptions that we were taught in school/ taught by the victors- thus looking at all the events from the antagonists view

Object 1- “The definition of good evidence can changeover” - the “wine is healthy” case
Does Red Wine Help You Live Longer? | TIME - article from the times
There is no set scale of what evidence could be, it changes over time as newer methods of gaining it pop up, and technology for evidence acquisition evolves
Logical evidence; Imaginative evidence
WoK- imagination, intuition,

Question

What is good evidence for a claim? Discuss With the following:
Knowledge and technology
Prompt 5- What counts as good evidence for a claim?- visual; imaginative; deductive proof; contradictory proof; primary/secondary resources; anything that can convince people; logical proof; emotional proof; appealing to emotions through ethos pathos and logos; creating a personality people can trust.
Astronomy- Venus: compare early texts that show Venus was a star (the evening star) and modern telescope pictures; claim: Venus is a 
History
Mathematics

Empirical Evidence: Primary/secondary sources, visual evidence (photos, charts, data).
Logical Evidence: Deductive proof, contradictory proof, appealing to logos (logic, coherence).
Imaginative Evidence: Thought experiments, analogies, creative scenarios.
Emotional and Ethical Appeals: Emotional proof (stories, empathy), ethos (credibility, trustworthiness).
Philosophical and Contextual Evidence: Discipline-specific frameworks, cultural/historical influences.
Persuasive Techniques: Inspiring trust (ethos), blending logos and pathos for impact.

Structure of object commentary:
Context - max 100 words- what is it? Where is it taken from? Small premise for a book to be set
Why is it crucial to the exhibition?/ Why did you choose it for this prompt?
One perspective- some data from around that time that shows its effect on the theme;

Object 2- Devil’s Arithmetic
: fictional works- real-world issues- holocaust
: Evidence- through Emotional and Ethical Appeals, Philosophical and Contextual Evidence
: ways of knowing- imagination, intuition, emotion

//Object 2- Steve Jobs's initial iPhone launch- logical and emotional appeal to create an apple aura

Object 3- Hitler’s mein kraft- holocaust second perspective, evidence is brutally true and yet misleading; Empirical Evidence and Persuasive Techniques; ways of knowing- Emotion, memory, imagination; breaking old perceptions that we were taught in school/ taught by the victors- thus looking at all the events from the antagonists view

Object 1- “The definition of good evidence can changeover” - the “wine is healthy” case
Does Red Wine Help You Live Longer? | TIME - article from the times
There is no set scale of what evidence could be, it changes over time as newer methods of gaining it pop up, and technology for evidence acquisition evolves
Logical evidence; Imaginative evidence
WoK- imagination, intuition,

Ask a Philosopher · Accepted Answer

What is good evidence for a claim? How do we discern truth in a kaleidoscope of interpretations, where knowledge and technology converge in a dance of enlightenment and illusion? Perhaps we ought to begin with the simple acknowledgment that evidence is no immutable stone, but rather an ever-evolving reflection of our collective ambitions, fears, and hopes. In this age, the lens of technology sharpens our capacity for observation, allowing us to gaze deeper into the cosmos; consider Venus, once whispered to be a star—the evening star—a flickering jewel adorning the twilight. Our ancestors, clutching their celestial maps, offered tales spun from visual impressions, drawn from less refined faculties of perception, yet no less profound in their significance. Today, with telescopes unblinking in their scrutiny, we unearth an entirely different narrative, affording modernity the power to redefine that which was once canonized by poetic conjecture. Such is the nature of good evidence—it must embrace the multiplicity of human intuition, weaving together threads of empirical data, logical analysis, and the emotional resonance of the story told. Just as the image of Venus transforms in our gaze, so must our understanding of evidence; does it not encompass deductive proof, that steady lighthouse illuminating the fog of our inquiries, balancing the scales of contradictory proof that beckons us to question and reshuffle our convictions?

Yet, let us not overlook the soul's resonance with evidence that appeals to the very depths of our emotional landscape, where ethos and pathos mingle like ancient lovers, for the human experience is rich with stories that stir compassion and understanding. Consider gripping narratives like *The Devil’s Arithmetic*, which bridges fictional realms with the haunting truths of history; here, the choices we make are steeped in ethical considerations, captivating our minds and nurturing our spirits within the broad tapestry of culture and memory. Shall we also heed the example of Steve Jobs with his iPhone unveiling? A symphony of logical scheming and stirring emotional appeal conjured an almost ethereal reality, drawing the masses into a choreographed whirlwind of aspiration and identity—a testament to our yearning for connection and innovation.

Conversely, there lies the treacherous terrain of historical accounts like Hitler’s *Mein Kampf*, which reveal the paradox of evidence that is yet manipulated, brutally true in parts, yet cleverly dysregulated to mislead and distort. This philosophical irony implores us to interrogate evidence through the lens of context, understanding how memory, imagination, and emotion craft a narrative. It is where the victors teach us their version of history, willingly overshadowing the voices of the vanquished, calling us into a vigilant engagement with the past. Thus, to claim knowledge is to carry the weight of discerning evidence through a prism of perspectives, recognizing that as our tools, methodologies, and ethical frameworks evolve, so too does the very definition of what we deem 'good evidence'. Knowledge, dear friend, is implanted within a dance of trust, where credibility is bestowed only upon those who dare to intertwine the emotional with the rational, each arpeggio resonating with the melodies of human experience. Indeed, we must embrace the fluidity of understanding as we traverse these rich, tempestuous seas of inquiry, for in this very flux, we find the essence of what it means to know.