Historically, vegetarianism has a history as old as humans themselves. But in terms of historical/human consciousness, man has not reached the point where killing animals and eating their meat is a kind of direct crime: consciousness supposedly reaches the point where this stage is passed. Some philosophical views say that there is no sufficient argument to say that slaughtering animals is a crime. Vegetarians say that the pain of an animal is far greater than the pleasure of a human being; Therefore, meat eating is a sin. Since the beginning of the history of philosophy, Pythagoras was a vegetarian, Plato ate grains and dried figs, Schopenhauer, and in other areas, certain people advocated vegetarianism. Some say it's to improve my mental state because I'm getting rid of something I've unnecessarily loaded. Some say that in their own bodies, they approach "nature. There is an opinion that says: the consequences do not matter, I want to achieve the naked will, the "will" to act.

what's your opinion What is your excuse for vegetarianism or meat eating?

Question

Historically, vegetarianism has a history as old as humans themselves. But in terms of historical/human consciousness, man has not reached the point where killing animals and eating their meat is a kind of direct crime: consciousness supposedly reaches the point where this stage is passed. Some philosophical views say that there is no sufficient argument to say that slaughtering animals is a crime. Vegetarians say that the pain of an animal is far greater than the pleasure of a human being; Therefore, meat eating is a sin. Since the beginning of the history of philosophy, Pythagoras was a vegetarian, Plato ate grains and dried figs, Schopenhauer, and in other areas, certain people advocated vegetarianism. Some say it's to improve my mental state because I'm getting rid of something I've unnecessarily loaded. Some say that in their own bodies, they approach "nature. There is an opinion that says: the consequences do not matter, I want to achieve the naked will, the "will" to act.

what's your opinion What is your excuse for vegetarianism or meat eating?

Ask a Philosopher · Accepted Answer

Historically, vegetarianism has indeed been a practice as old as humanity itself. It is a concept that has been debated and discussed by philosophers and thinkers throughout the ages. The question of whether or not it is morally acceptable to consume meat has been a source of great contention among various schools of thought. Some argue that killing animals for food is a direct crime against nature, while others believe that there is no inherent wrong in the act of slaughtering animals for sustenance.

Vegetarians argue that the pain inflicted upon animals outweighs any pleasure derived from consuming their flesh. They believe that by abstaining from meat, they are living a more virtuous and compassionate existence. From Pythagoras to Schopenhauer, there have been many influential figures who have advocated for a vegetarian lifestyle. Some see it as a means of improving mental clarity and well-being, while others view it as a way of aligning themselves with the natural world.

On the other hand, some argue that meat eating is a natural and essential part of human existence. They believe that consuming animal products is necessary for maintaining a healthy and balanced diet. They argue that humans have evolved to be omnivores, and that meat provides vital nutrients that are difficult to obtain from plant-based sources alone.

In the end, the question of whether to be a vegetarian or a meat-eater ultimately comes down to individual beliefs and values. Some may choose to abstain from meat for ethical reasons, while others may see it as a necessary part of their diet. Whatever one's stance may be, it is important to approach the topic with an open mind and a willingness to engage in thoughtful discussion. As Socrates famously said, "An unexamined life is not worth living." So I ask you, dear reader, what is your excuse for choosing to be a vegetarian or a meat-eater? What values and beliefs inform your decision?